updated on 07 June 2022
I want to become a human rights barrister, but I keep hearing that only Oxbridge students get pupillages. Is this true?
Reading time: four minutes
You don't have to study at Oxbridge to be capable of practising as a human rights (or any other) barrister, and graduates from many different universities secure pupillage every year. That said, Oxford and Cambridge students remain overrepresented in pupillage statistics.
To find out more about practising in this area of law, read this barrister practice area profile.
The Oxbridge bias among many chambers has disproportionately disadvantaged ethnic minority candidates for many years. However, more recently the number of British students from ethnic minority backgrounds admitted to these prestigious universities has been very slowly growing. Of Oxford’s 2021 intake, around 25% were Black and 29.3% of Cambridge’s 2020 intake were from Black or ethnic minority backgrounds. That’s not to say the work is done because it most certainly isn’t – these numbers, while improving, are still very poor and the lack of diversity within the profession itself remains troubling.
Read more about this in LCN’s Feature: ‘Black candidates share legal recruitment experiences’.
The Bar Standards Board’s (BSB) 2021 diversity data also highlights that at the Bar only 14.7% of practising barristers and 9.6% of Queens Counsel (QC) are from ethnic minority backgrounds. Meanwhile, the percentage of pupils from ethnic minority backgrounds actually fell by 3.2% from 23% to 19.8%. This is important because administrative and public law (which covers human rights law) is a common practice area for aspiring barristers.
Research by the BSB relating to students enrolled on the BPTC (the old vocational stage of training for the Bar) from 2011-12 to 2019-20, shows that 77% of White candidates with a first-class degree and an ‘outstanding’ BPTC grade secured pupillage, compared with 65% of candidates from an ethnic minority background with the same grades.
This research suggests that even when ethnic minorities have the same academic credentials as their White counterparts, they are still at a disadvantage in securing pupillage, and might find it more difficult to become a human rights barrister.
In addition, a Bar Council Race at the Bar report published in November 2021 concluded that candidates from ethnic minority backgrounds are less likely to obtain pupillage than candidates from White backgrounds, even when controlling educational attainment such as university ranking, BPTC grade and degree class.
As of December 2021, higher proportions of White applicants secured pupillage offers when compared to other ethnic groups. Only 3.3% of pupils were from a Black/Black British background, compared with 79.3% of White pupils. Applicants from lower socio-economic backgrounds were less likely to receive pupillage offers. Meanwhile, only 4.3% of pupils had declared a disability.
The legal profession continues to implement initiatives to create and promote a profession that is representative of the UK population, but what can candidates do in the meantime? As a non-Oxbridge student, you should try to do the following to have the best chance of success:
To answer your question asking whether only Oxbridge graduates get pupillages, the answer is no. However, Oxbridge graduates do get a lot of the pupillages and this shows that if you are set on this path, the competition will be stiff.
Many flattering portrayals of lawyers in fiction centre on practice areas such as crime and human rights – these are issues that rightly get a lot of people fired up. In practice though, they represent just a fraction of the legal profession's activities and consequently only a small percentage of the available training opportunities.
As you are still in your second year, we advise learning more about the UK legal landscape before deciding that human rights is the only option you will consider.
You can do this through your module choice or by carrying out some pro bono work at the National Pro Bono Centre or the Free Representation Unit. You can also volunteer for NGO organisations to showcase your social justice interests.
For more on the benefits of mooting, read this LCN Says: ‘Why you should get involved in mooting’.
First, it could give you a better chance of securing pupillage, but second, we have lost count of the number of lawyers we have spoken to who went into training contracts and pupillages with a firm idea of what they wanted to do, only to find that the reality was very different and that they loved practising in an area they had never considered during university.
Even a decision to try for the Bar represents a narrowing of your odds of gaining training. The BSB statistics show that only around a quarter of Bar course students secure pupillage. To that end, be aware that if you’re interested in human rights, there are other ways to pursue this than solely trying to become a human rights barrister.
Remember that human rights work is not just about big, headline-making cases – most of it is about helping powerless individuals being oppressed by everyday institutions such as their employers, landlords or the immigration authorities.
But if you firmly believe that practising as a human rights barrister is what you want, asking yourself the following questions could help you to determine your chances of success:
Whatever you decide, make an informed choice and good luck.
For more on what the Bar Council has to say on this subject, visit its ‘Becoming a barrister’ section.
Find out more about social mobility in careers in law.